THE ASAHI SHIMBUN
November 4, 2020 at 15:25 JST
An end to the legal and diplomatic dispute between Tokyo and Seoul is nowhere in sight, two years after the South Korean Supreme Court ordered Japanese companies to pay compensation to wartime laborers.
South Korean officials had expected Prime Minister Yoshihide Suga to take a more lenient stance by emphasizing closer economic ties and moving away from the hard-line position of his predecessor, Shinzo Abe.
However, Japan rejected an informal proposal from Seoul that the South Korean government would reimburse the Japanese companies at a later date if they agreed to pay the entire compensation amount.
Japanese officials feared that accepting the proposal would lead to more lawsuits against Japanese companies that used Korean workers during the colonial rule over the Korean Peninsula between 1910 and 1945.
Japan’s position has long been that the 1965 bilateral agreement settled all compensation claims by South Korea from World War II.
According to sources in the Japanese and South Korean governments, the South Korean president’s office this year set up a team led by Noh Young-min, the president’s chief of staff, to consider various measures to resolve the wartime laborers’ issue as a way to improve bilateral ties.
Although South Korean President Moon Jae-in has long insisted that the Supreme Court ruling must be respected, he did give the go-ahead for the proposals that were put together.
In spring, South Korea proposed to reimburse the Japanese companies later if they agreed to pay the compensation amount in line with the Supreme Court ruling.
Japanese officials believed that accepting the offer would essentially be agreeing with the court orders.
In the Oct. 30, 2018, ruling, the South Korean Supreme Court ordered Nippon Steel Corp. to compensate wartime workers. The following month, a similar ruling was handed down against Mitsubishi Heavy Industries Ltd.
After both companies refused to follow the top court’s orders, South Korean courts started procedures to seize the assets of the two companies in South Korea, such as stocks and patents, and sell them for cash to cover the compensation.
Tokyo has argued that the South Korean Supreme Court ruling violated international law.
Regarding the move to sell off the seized assets, Foreign Minister Toshimitsu Motegi has said, “That would lead to a very serious situation.”
In August, when he was still chief Cabinet secretary, Suga said that every measure would be considered if South Korea went ahead and sold off the assets.
Sources said the Abe administration considered about 40 different retaliatory measures, including halting the issuing of visas to public servants and recalling Japanese Ambassador Koji Tomita from Seoul.
Conservative elements within the ruling Liberal Democratic Party considered even more drastic measures, such as restricting direct investment in South Korea and seizing assets held in Japan by South Korean companies, according to sources.
However, sources said that since Suga took over as prime minister he has instructed officials to consider more moderate measures to somehow improve the bilateral relationship.
That stance led Nam Gwan-pyo, the South Korean ambassador to Japan, to report to the South Korean National Assembly on Oct. 21 that Suga was taking a more realistic approach that had contributed to a more positive atmosphere.
On the same day, Lee Nak-yeon, the head of the ruling Democratic Party of Korea, said at a news conference, “I hope the issue can be resolved before the Tokyo Olympics next summer.”
The Moon administration, which cannot interfere with the judicial process, also knows that selling the assets of the Japanese companies would further worsen ties with Japan.
The novel coronavirus pandemic has also had a deep negative impact on the South Korean economy, and Seoul cannot ignore the effects from stricter export restrictions imposed by Tokyo in retaliation for the South Korean Supreme Court rulings.
In an attempt to resolve the thorny issue, various channels are being explored, including the one between Shigeru Kitamura, the head of the National Security Secretariat, and Suh Hoon, Moon’s national security adviser.
Kitamura and Hoon worked together on the issue of Japanese nationals abducted by North Korea in their respective past positions.
(This article was written by Takuya Suzuki in Seoul and Ryutaro Abe and Yuki Nikaido in Tokyo.)
Visit this page for the latest news on Japan’s battle with the novel coronavirus pandemic.
Haruki Murakami and other writers read from books before selected audiences at the new Haruki Murakami Library.
The Asahi Shimbun aims “to achieve gender equality and empower all women and girls” through its Gender Equality Declaration.
Let’s explore the Japanese capital from the viewpoint of wheelchair users and people with disabilities with Barry Joshua Grisdale.